Hynes-Tawa

AAWM JOURNAL VOL. 9 NO. 1 (2021)

Tonic, Final, Kyū: Tonal Mappings in the Meiji Period and Beyond

Liam Hynes-Tawa

---

Abstract:

This article discusses the state of music theory in late-nineteenth- and early-twentieth-century Japan, where musicians were invested in finding ways to map theories of traditional Japanese music and those of European tonality onto each other. By focusing on two theorists from the late nineteenth century (Isawa Shūji and Uehara Rokushirō) and one from soon after World War II (Koizumi Fumio), I demonstrate the coexistence of many contradictory ways of analyzing much of the music that came out of this period and afterward. My analysis of their various types of mapping draws out the cultural implications and goals that lie behind their strategies, which reflect the different ways in which they were hoping to situate Japanese music in a wider global context, whether as part of nineteenth-century nation-building or postwar reemergence.

Through analysis of several pieces written between the early twentieth and early twenty-first centuries, I suggest that the most effective lens is one that freely borrows elements from various theorists and traditions to create analyses that are as hybridized as the pieces themselves. Examples are drawn from a wide variety of genres—children’s songs, wartime soldiers’ songs, enka (nostalgic popular music), and film music—to demonstrate the wide reach of these hybridized tonal systems. By extension, analogous models could also be applied to musical traditions elsewhere in the world that blend Western tonal and non-Western elements.

Read full article in PDF version

Keywords: Japan, tonality, modality, enka, min’yō, tetrachords, solfège, history of theory

Contributor Information:

Liam Hynes-Tawa is a lecturer in the Department of Music at Yale University.

Corrections:

• The solfège syllable 徵in Mandarin is pronounced zhǐ, not zhī—third tone, not first tone.
• Nakane’s treatise is slightly mistitled in the bibliography, with 源 rather than 原 (though it is correct in the main text).

© 2021 by the author. Users may read, download, copy, distribute, print, search, or link to the full texts of this article without requesting permission. When distributing, (1) the author of the article and the name, volume, issue, and year of the journal must be identified clearly; (2) no portion of the article, including audio, video, or other accompanying media, may be used for commercial purposes; and (3) no portion of the article or any of its accompanying media may be modified, transformed, built upon, sampled, remixed, or separated from the rest of the article.

---